Freight Train Town: Why Carrboro, North Carolina, Is More Than the Other Half of Chapel Hill
Carrboro, North Carolina, began as a rail terminus and cotton mill village beside Chapel Hill. Its rail line, its namesake's record and Libba Cotten's song explain what it became.
Published November 7, 2026 · 10 min read · Let's Live There editorial · Updated November 7, 2026
Around 1905, a girl of eleven or twelve was living in a neighborhood called West End, just outside Chapel Hill, North Carolina. She had learned music on her older brother's banjo. At nine she left school to work as a domestic, and by twelve she had a live-in housekeeping job; her mother saved the dollar-a-month wages to buy her a guitar of her own. She was left-handed, so she turned the instrument upside down, played the bass strings with her fingers and picked the melody with her thumb. Trains ran close to her home, and she wrote a song about them. The song was "Freight Train." The girl was Elizabeth Cotten, known as Libba, and West End is now the town of Carrboro.
That origin is a good place to start, because it contains almost everything that makes Carrboro distinct from the famous college town beside it. The railroad is why the town exists. The mill the railroad fed is why the town has its name. Cotten grew up in West End and went to work as a child, keeping house for other families.
The line that stopped short
Chapel Hill got its railroad late and only partway. In 1882 a short spur opened from University Station, near Glenn, North Carolina, down to a depot west of the village — a roughly 10-mile branch built, in part, because state law required the tracks to stay at least a mile from campus. The tracks ended about a mile from Franklin Street, among farmland and a few houses. The settlement that grew up around the depot took the name West End. Goods, lumber and travelers bound for the university arrived there, and the hauling and storage businesses that served the campus could set up nearby without being on it.
In 1898 a local businessman, Thomas Lloyd, built a cotton mill beside the tracks. Mills need rail access and cheap labor, and West End had both. The mill brought workers, the workers needed houses, and the houses needed a town. West End incorporated in 1911 as Venable, honoring Francis Preston Venable, then president of the university. The name lasted about two years.
Why it is called Carrboro
Julian Shakespeare Carr was one of the richest men in North Carolina. He made a fortune in Durham on Bull Durham tobacco, then built Durham Hosiery Mills into a large textile concern. He gave generously to churches, colleges and causes across the state. His company took over the Lloyd mill and brought electric power to it, and in 1913 the town renamed itself Carrboro in his honor.
The same year, Carr gave a speech at the University of North Carolina dedicating the Confederate monument that students later called Silent Sam. He praised the Confederate army for preserving what he called the Anglo-Saxon race in the South. He also told the crowd that shortly after the war, near that spot, he had horsewhipped a Black woman for what he considered an insult to a white woman. The speech sat in his papers at the university for nearly a century before a 2011 letter to the student newspaper brought it to wide attention.
Carr was not a fringe figure. He was a Confederate veteran who embraced the title "General" from veterans' organizations. He was a leading Democrat in the era when the party campaigned openly on white supremacy. And he was a philanthropist celebrated across the state. He held all three roles at once, publicly and without apparent embarrassment. That coexistence is what makes him worth understanding rather than simply condemning.
Cotten was working as a housekeeper for the Seeger family in Washington when they discovered that she could play. Her recording career began about a decade later, when she was in her sixties. Those recordings made "Freight Train" a folk standard and her upside-down picking style a model for generations of guitarists. She won a Grammy in 1985, two years before she died, and was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2022.
Carrboro has argued with its own name for years. A 2011 letter to the student newspaper revived attention to Carr's 1913 remarks, and calls to rename the town followed, including a 2016 request from a former mayor to the town board. Because a name change would require state legislative approval, the town kept the name and, in 2019, erected a plaque near Town Hall that states plainly who Carr was and what he said. Carrboro chose to keep the name and attach the record to it, having the argument in public rather than settling it by erasure.
The tracks are still there
The spur still runs through the middle of Carrboro, crossing downtown streets at grade. Passenger service ended in 1936. The university the line was built to serve still runs a coal-burning cogeneration plant in Chapel Hill; it has repeatedly pledged to stop burning coal and has missed its own deadlines for doing so. A town whose first reason for existing still crosses its main streets has something almost stubborn about it.
A mill town that found a second life
Durham Hosiery's operation in Carrboro ended in the 1930s, and other textile tenants came and went in the decades after. By the 1970s the mill building stood empty and faced demolition, and residents campaigned to save it.
What changed the town, beginning in that decade, was a cluster of community institutions that took root downtown. Two of them gave old buildings new uses:
- The mill was converted into Carr Mill Mall in 1977. A cooperative grocery, Weaver Street Market, later opened in it with a lawn out front.
- The farmers' market started in 1979. It admits only growers and makers from within about 50 miles, and on Saturday mornings it fills the Town Commons.
- Cat's Cradle, a rock club that had moved around Chapel Hill since 1969, settled on East Main Street in the early 1990s. It became one of the best-known small venues in the Southeast.
- The ArtsCenter, a community arts school and theater founded in 1974, moved in 2023 into a renovated existing building on Roberson Street. It is one more old structure given a second life.
None of these is a tourist attraction in the ordinary sense. They are everyday institutions that happen to be unusually good. Together they gave a mill town a second identity as a place people chose on purpose. The Weaver Street lawn is the clearest symbol, and its best-known story shows how the town thinks.
For years a man named Bruce Thomas danced on that lawn, alone and happily, to whatever music was playing. The lawn belongs to the mall, which is why its management could, and in 2006 did, tell him to stop. The response from residents was loud enough that the matter was settled in his favor. Legally the lawn was private property. In practice the town had decided it was a commons, and it won the argument.
The politics followed the same pattern:
- In 1977 Carrboro elected Robert Drakeford, its first Black mayor, who served until 1983.
- In the 1990s it extended domestic partner benefits to town employees, among the earliest North Carolina governments to do so.
- In 1995 it elected Mike Nelson, the first openly gay mayor of any North Carolina municipality.
- In 2023 it elected Barbara Foushee as mayor.
It has long called itself, with a straight face and a wink at the same time, the Paris of the Piedmont. For a town of about 21,000 people, Carrboro has an outsized habit of being first at things. That has made it a reference point for progressive small-town government in the South.
The part the lawn does not show
The reckoning with Carr's name is the visible part of a longer story. Rogers Road is a historically Black community on the northwestern edge of Chapel Hill and Carrboro. In 1972 it was chosen as the site of the Orange County landfill, which operated for more than forty years. During that time the neighborhood went without public sewer service and lived with the smells, the truck traffic and worries about well water. The landfill closed in 2013. Sewer lines arrived only after a long campaign by residents and years of negotiation among the county, Chapel Hill and Carrboro.
The town that was among the first in the state to grant partner benefits was also, for most of that time, one of the governments that left the landfill where it was. Both facts belong in any honest portrait of the place.
The current argument is about housing. Carrboro is small, mostly built out and expensive, and affordable housing has become a pressing local issue for the town. A downtown apartment or a bungalow in the old mill village costs what scarce housing near a major university costs. Downtown is gaining civic scale too: the Drakeford Library Complex, a joint project of the town and Orange County named for the 1977 mayor, opened in 2025 with a new county library branch.
What it is like now, concretely
Carrboro covers roughly six and a half square miles, mostly residential streets around a compact downtown along Main, Weaver and Greensboro streets. Beginning in the early 1990s, a substantial wave of Latino immigrants arrived, many working in the region's construction and service trades. By the early 2000s they made up roughly an eighth of the town.
Chapel Hill Transit has been fare-free since 2002. Carrboro funds it jointly with Chapel Hill and the university, and several routes link Carrboro with the campus and the hospital. Free is not the same as frequent on every route at every hour. Check current routes and schedules before relying on a bus, especially for the ride home after an evening show.
The everyday texture of the place is concentrated within a few blocks. The farmers' market fills the Town Commons on Saturday mornings. The co-op lawn serves as a front porch for half the town. A club on East Main books touring bands most nights. Small, locally owned shops, cafes and restaurants line the streets in between. Each fall the Carrboro Music Festival puts free performances in bars, restaurants, churches and outdoor stages around downtown.
If you are deciding whether Carrboro would suit you, the trade-offs are fairly clear.
It fits people who:
- want to live near downtown or on a good bus route, work somewhere those routes reach, such as the campus or the hospital, and would like to drive less
- care about local food and local music
- want a town government small enough to walk into and argue with
- can afford Orange County prices
It fits less well if you:
- want a large house with land for the money
- commute to Raleigh
- would live on the town's outer edges and still expect to go car-free
- want a place where nobody will ask you to sign a petition
Carrboro is a separately incorporated town with its own council, its own police, its own long memory and its own grudges. It shares a school district and a bus system with Chapel Hill, but its founding story — the rail spur that stopped short, the mill, Carr's name — is its own.
What the argument built
Carrboro didn't come together from a single plan. It grew one decision at a time:
- A railroad ended a mile short of the village.
- A mill went up beside the tracks.
- A rich man's company bought the mill, and the town took his name.
- A girl in a segregated neighborhood wrote a song that outlived them all.
Much of what followed has been the town arguing, in public, about which parts of that inheritance to keep.
The mill is a grocery store. The tracks still cross Main Street. The name is still on the sign, with a plaque near Town Hall explaining why it is uncomfortable. That is the reason to walk the mile from Franklin Street to the Weaver Street lawn and see what the argument has built.
Places in this story
Verified sources retained in this article’s legacy package.
Write to the editor
Spotted an error? Tell us privately. A person reads every note; nothing is published.