Skip to main content

Side-by-side

Smithtown, NY vs St. James, NY

Scores are 0–100, higher is better. “Best in row” marks the one place with the highest score on a measure.

The plates show each place’s average across every measure. Take the two-minute survey to see your own fit →

Where they differ

The 5 measures with the widest gap between the scores.

  • Walkability16 apart
  • Short commutes15 apart
  • Small-town feel7 apart
  • Diversity6 apart
  • Low property tax5 apart

A · SmithtownB · St. James

The full table

Scores are 0–100, higher is better. Best in row marks the one highest score; equal scores are not marked.

Scores for Smithtown, St. James, grouped by category
MeasureSmithtown, NYSt. James, NY

Cost & Taxes

3029
Affordability1919
Housing cost3336
Low state taxes1717
Low property tax4944
What’s measured

Affordability

What is measured for Affordability: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Price levelU.S. average = 100, BEA 2024112.6112.6
Measured forNew York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro areaNew York-Newark-Jersey City, NY-NJ metro area
Housing rents price level148.6148.6

Housing cost

What is measured for Housing cost: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Median home$704,700$652,700
Price-to-income4.7×4.6×
Median rent$2,020/mo$2,218/mo

Low state taxes

What is measured for Low state taxes: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
State income taxTop rate 10.9%Top rate 10.9%
Sales tax8.53%4% state + 4.53% average local8.53%4% state + 4.53% average local

Low property tax

What is measured for Low property tax: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Effective property tax rate1.42% of home value1.53% of home value

Work & Economy

6260
Job market7878
Remote-work infrastructure7974
Growing community2929
What’s measured

Job market

What is measured for Job market: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Unemployment rate3.4%3.4%

Remote-work infrastructure

What is measured for Remote-work infrastructure: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Households with a broadband subscriptionCensus ACS95%92.6%

Growing community

What is measured for Growing community: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Population change since 2020+0.7%+0.7%

Climate & Weather

4949
Warm climate4848
Cool climate5252
Four seasons9595
Sunshine4040
Low humidity2525
Winter daylight3535
What’s measured

Warm climate

What is measured for Warm climate: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
January high39.2°F39.2°F
July high82.8°F82.8°F
NOAA 1991–2020 normals stationIslip Li Macarthur AP, NY, 7.4 miIslip Li Macarthur AP, NY, 6.3 mi

Cool climate

What is measured for Cool climate: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
January high39.2°F39.2°F
July high82.8°F82.8°F
NOAA 1991–2020 normals stationIslip Li Macarthur AP, NY, 7.4 miIslip Li Macarthur AP, NY, 6.3 mi

Four seasons

What is measured for Four seasons: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
January high39.2°F39.2°F
July high82.8°F82.8°F
NOAA 1991–2020 normals stationIslip Li Macarthur AP, NY, 7.4 miIslip Li Macarthur AP, NY, 6.3 mi

Sunshine

What is measured for Sunshine: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Share of possible sunshine received (estimated)about 58%about 58%
NOAA cloudiness stationBRIDGEPORT, CT, 21 miBRIDGEPORT, CT, 20 mi
How it is estimatedThe nearest NOAA station with a sunshine record is more than 50 miles away, so the share is estimated from this station’s clear, partly cloudy and cloudy days by a fixed fitted rule (typically within about 3 points).The nearest NOAA station with a sunshine record is more than 50 miles away, so the share is estimated from this station’s clear, partly cloudy and cloudy days by a fixed fitted rule (typically within about 3 points).

Low humidity

What is measured for Low humidity: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
July mean dew point64.1°F64.1°F
NOAA hourly-normals stationBridgeport Sikorsky MEM AP, CT, 21 miBridgeport Sikorsky MEM AP, CT, 20 mi
Annual rainfall46 in46 in

Lower is drier.

Winter daylight

What is measured for Winter daylight: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Daylight at the December solstice, hours9.29.2

Nature & Environment

6565
Outdoor recreation4342
Public land access3333
Near the ocean or a Great Lake8990
Air quality7474
Drinking water8686
What’s measured

Outdoor recreation

What is measured for Outdoor recreation: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Open public land in the countyPAD-US 4.06.2%6.2%
Near mountainsNoNo
Elevation, ftUSGS 3DEP54145
Terrain relief within 20 mi, fthighest point of the ring minus the place840
Terrain relief within 40 mi, fthighest point of the ring minus the place555416
Nearest coast, miNatural Earth coastline3.5ocean3.3ocean
Within 30 miles of the coastYesYes

Public land access

What is measured for Public land access: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Open public land in the countyPAD-US 4.06.2%6.2%

Near the ocean or a Great Lake

What is measured for Near the ocean or a Great Lake: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Nearest coast, miNatural Earth coastline3.5ocean3.3ocean
Within 30 miles of the coastYesYes

Air quality

What is measured for Air quality: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Annual median AQI3838

Lower is cleaner.

Drinking water

What is measured for Drinking water: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Share of residents on a system with a recent health-based violation, 2023–2025 (lower scores higher)2.6%2.6%
Health-based violations per 10,000 people served0.00.0
Community water systems counted (county)2626

Regulatory violations, not taste or hardness.

Safety & Health

9292
Low crimeunknownunknown
Low disaster risk9696
Health care access8787
What’s measured

Low crime

What is measured for Low crime: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Low crime rateunknownunknown

Low disaster risk

What is measured for Low disaster risk: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Expected property loss$708 per $1M of property per year$708 per $1M of property per year
Overall riskRelatively High (97/100)Relatively High (97/100)
Winter weatherVery High, about 10 events a yearVery High, about 10 events a year
Coastal floodingVery High, about 3.8 events a yearVery High, about 3.8 events a year
Inland floodingRelatively High, about 3.5 events a yearRelatively High, about 3.5 events a year
HurricaneRelatively High, 20% chance a yearRelatively High, 20% chance a year

Health care access

What is measured for Health care access: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Physicians per 100k residents (county)386386
Primary-care physicians per 100k7171
Hospital beds per 100k225225
Nearest hospitalSt. Catherine of Siena Hospital, 0.6 miSuny/Stony Brook University Hospital, Stony Brook, 3.3 mi
Nearest hospital rated 3+ starsSt. Catherine of Siena Hospital, 0.6 mi (5 stars)Suny/Stony Brook University Hospital, Stony Brook, 3.3 mi (5 stars)
Hospitals within 30 mi2019
Best rating within 30 mi5 of 5 stars5 of 5 stars

Getting Around

4855
Walkability2844
Public transit49
Short commutes2742
Airport access9594
Close to a major city8887
What’s measured

Walkability

What is measured for Walkability: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Walkability indexEPA Smart Location Database7.6 of 209.7 of 20

Public transit

What is measured for Public transit: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Transit service near homesEPA Smart Location Database0.2 trips an hour at evening peak0.6 trips an hour at evening peak
Typical distance to a transit stop, m920863

Short commutes

What is measured for Short commutes: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Mean commute, min3329
CongestionNot measured here; the score uses commute time aloneNot measured here; the score uses commute time alone

Airport access

What is measured for Airport access: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Scheduled airports within 60 mi77
Nearest airport with scheduled serviceISP, 7.3 miISP, 6.1 mi
Nearest large airportJFK, 33 miJFK, 37 mi

Close to a major city

What is measured for Close to a major city: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Nearest metro of 1M+ peopleNew York, NY43 mi straight-lineNew York, NY46 mi straight-line

Amenities & Entertainment

7878
Cultural amenities9292
Performing arts & museums8989
Golf course access5454
What’s measured

Cultural amenities

What is measured for Cultural amenities: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Arts, entertainment & recreation establishments (county)940940
Restaurants & food-service establishments (county)3,8353,835
Population24,37513,244
Pro sportsunknownunknown
Power-4 college sportsNonone within 30 milesNonone within 30 miles
Performing-arts companies in the county4646
Event promoters in the county4444
Museums and historic sites in the county4949

Performing arts & museums

What is measured for Performing arts & museums: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Performing-arts companies in the county4646
Event promoters in the county4444
Museums and historic sites in the county4949

Golf course access

What is measured for Golf course access: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Golf courses and country clubs in the county62 establishments62 establishments
Golf courses per 100,000 county residents4.14.1

Community & People

4645
Small-town feel8592
Big-city feel126
Younger community2119
Older community7981
Diversity4034
Educated population7471
Conservative community5858
Progressive community4242
Religious community33
What’s measured

Small-town feel

What is measured for Small-town feel: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Population24,37513,244

Big-city feel

What is measured for Big-city feel: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Population24,37513,244

Younger community

What is measured for Younger community: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Median age, yrs4747.4

Older community

What is measured for Older community: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Median age, yrs4747.4
Residents aged 65+19%22.6%

Diversity

What is measured for Diversity: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Diversity index (0–1)0.400.34
Population24,37513,244
LGBTQ+ friendlinessunknownunknown

Educated population

What is measured for Educated population: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Adults with a bachelor's degree or higher51.2%49.7%

Conservative community

What is measured for Conservative community: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
GOP vote share55%55%

Progressive community

What is measured for Progressive community: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
GOP vote share55%55%

Religious community

What is measured for Religious community: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Congregations per 100k county residents47.647.6
Congregations in the county (all faiths)726726
Adherents of all faiths67% of residents67% of residents

Families & Schools

5151
Education9797
Private school selection2020
Affordable childcare3636
Childcare availabilityunknownunknown
What’s measured

Education

What is measured for Education: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Pupil-teacher ratiocounty figure11.511.5
Per-pupil spending$34,000$34,000
UniversityStony Brook University, 6.4 mi · 30,700 studentsStony Brook University, 3.1 mi · 30,700 students
College townNoYes

Private school selection

What is measured for Private school selection: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Private schools per 100k33

Affordable childcare

What is measured for Affordable childcare: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Infant carestate median, 2022$300/wk$300/wk

Childcare availability

What is measured for Childcare availability: Smithtown, St. James
Measure A: Smithtown, NY B: St. James, NY
Childcare availabilityunknownunknown

Raw data

The measured figures behind the scores, county or state level where the label says so. Every figure and its source is on each place’s page.

Raw figures for Smithtown, St. James
FigureSmithtown, NYSt. James, NY
Population24,37513,244
Price Level (BEA RPP)112.6 (avg=100)112.6 (avg=100)
Median Home Price$704,700$652,700
Median Rent / mo$2,020$2,218
State Income Tax (top)10.9%10.9%
Sales Tax (state + avg local)8.53%8.53%
Unemployment Rate3.4%3.4%
Broadband Subscription95%93%
Coworking / 100kunknownunknown
Violent Crimes / 100k (FBI)unknownunknown
Property Crimes / 100k (FBI)unknownunknown
Jan High (°F)39.2°F39.2°F
Jul High (°F)82.8°F82.8°F
Possible Sunshine58%58%
July Dew Point (°F)64.1°F64.1°F
Annual Snow (in)31.8"31.8"
Annual Rain (in)46.0"46.0"
Annual AQI3838
Physicians / 100k (county)386386
Hospital Beds / 100k225225
Miles to 3+ Star Hospital0.6 mi3.3 mi
Residents on a system w/ violation3%3%
Walkability Index (EPA)7.6/209.7/20
Transit Trips / hour0.20.6
Avg Commute (min)33.2 min29.4 min
Congestion Delay (h/yr)unknownunknown
Major Airports (60 mi)77
Public Land % (county)6%6%
Miles to the Coast (ocean or Great Lakes)3.5 mi3.3 mi
Elevation (USGS 3DEP)54 ft145 ft
Terrain Relief within 20 mi84 ft0 ft
Terrain Relief within 40 mi555 ft416 ft
Golf Courses / 100k (county)4.14.1
Performing-Arts Companies (county)4646
Event Promoters (county)4444
Museums & Historic Sites (county)4949
Weekly Childcare Cost$300.00$300.00
Childcare Desert %unknownunknown
Private Schools / 100k3.03.0
Congregations / 100k (county)4848
Adherents / 1,000 (county)672672
GOP Vote Share55%55%
Median Age47.0 yrs47.4 yrs
Pop. Change Since 2020+0.7%+0.7%
Bachelor's Degree+51%50%
Miles to Nearest 1M+ Metro43 mi46 mi
Winter Daylight (hrs)9.29.2
Near MountainsNoNo
College TownNoYes
Smithtown, NY vs St. James, NY