New York · Mid-Atlantic
Highland-on-the-Lake, NY
Highland-on-the-Lake is a small town of about 3,584 people in New York, part of the Mid-Atlantic region of the United States.
A distinctive small town (2,500 to 9,999 residents): on the coast.
About Highland-on-the-Lake
Highland-on-the-Lake is a small town of about 3,584 people in New York, part of the Mid-Atlantic region of the United States. Overall prices in the Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY metro area are roughly in line with the U.S. average (index 95.8, where 100 is average). The median home runs about $186,300, well below the national median, and typical rent is around $1,000 a month, below the national median.
Expect harsh winters (January highs around 30°F), warm summers (July highs near 77°F), and a fair amount of cloud cover, with heavy snowfall (about 168 inches a year) and a wet climate overall. The setting offers the Great Lakes shore 2 mi away. The crime figure for Highland-on-the-Lake is county-level: Erie County Sheriff's Office, whose jurisdiction is the county's unincorporated area or a wider area than the place itself, reported about 33 violent and 529 property crimes per 100,000 residents in 2025. FEMA rates winter weather risk here as very high and inland flooding and tornado risk as relatively high. Community water systems serving about <1% of the county's residents had a health-based drinking-water violation in 2023–2025 (EPA records of regulatory violations, not taste or hardness).
Unemployment of 3.8% points to a healthy labor market, and New York's top state income tax rate is 10.9%. Property taxes run about 2.1% of home value, which is high for the U.S. It is an older community (median age 51, -0% population since 2020, and 19% of adults with a bachelor's degree). The largest university nearby is Bryant & Stratton College-Buffalo (about 4,200 students, 14 mi away). Day to day it is somewhat walkable with limited public transit, an average commute of about 26 minutes, and 2 major airports within about an hour. For health care, the nearest hospital with an emergency department is Mercy Hospital of Buffalo, Buffalo, about 13 mi away; the nearest rated three stars or better by Medicare is Kaleida Health, Buffalo, about 15 mi away. The county has about 429 physicians per 100,000 residents. For culture and entertainment, the area has NFL, NHL teams and 28 performing-arts companies and 21 museums and historic sites in the county.
Generated from this city's data
Through your eyes
The overview above comes from Highland-on-the-Lake’s data. This version is a short written summary of the place.
Score breakdown
0–100 · higher is always better · How we score
Plain averages. Take the survey to score this place against your priorities.
Around Highland-on-the-Lake
City data
- Median home price
- $186,300
- Median rent / mo
- $1,000
- Price level (BEA)
- 95.8 (100 = U.S. avg)
- Prices measured for
- Buffalo-Cheektowaga, NY metro area
- State income tax (top)
- 10.9%
- Sales tax (state + avg local)
- 8.53%
- Unemployment rate
- 3.8%
- Jan avg high
- 29.5°F
- Jul avg high
- 77.3°F
- Possible sunshine
- 47%
- July dew point
- 60.5°F
- Annual snowfall
- 167.6 in
- Annual rainfall
- 53.3 in
- Near mountains
- No
- Elevation
- 680 ft
- Terrain relief
- 651 ft within 20 mi, 1,530 ft within 40 mi
- Distance to coast
- 264 mi to the ocean, 2 mi to the Great Lakes
- Climate station
- Colden 1w, NY · 14 mi
Temperatures, snow and rain: NOAA 1991–2020 U.S. Climate Normals from the nearest station. Sunshine: NOAA Comparative Climatic Data, nearest station within 50 miles (sunny-day estimates elsewhere). Dew point: NOAA hourly normals, nearest station within 60 miles. Coast: straight-line distance to the nearest ocean or Great Lakes shore, Natural Earth 1:10m coastline (tidal rivers do not count). Elevation and terrain relief: USGS 3DEP Elevation Point Query Service; relief is the highest of eight points 20 (or 40) miles out minus the place, and mountains are a 2,000 ft rise within 20 miles or a 3,500 ft rise within 40 (otherwise the mountain flag is a hand estimate).
- Violent crime
- 33 per 100,000 residents
- Property crime
- 528.5 per 100,000 residents
- Crime figures from
- Erie County Sheriff's Office, county sheriff, county level (FBI Crime Data API, 2025)
Crime: FBI Crime Data API, calendar year 2025, per 100,000 residents of the population the agency covers. Violent = murder, rape, robbery and aggravated assault; property = burglary, larceny-theft, motor vehicle theft and arson. The figure is the place's own police agency or, where the FBI lists none of that name, the county sheriff for its own jurisdiction (usually the unincorporated area; labeled county level). An agency that did not report all 12 months has no figure here (never a zero); an original place then shows the older hand-assembled index, labeled as such.
- Walkability index (EPA)
- 11.0 / 20
- Transit trips per hour
- 0.7
- Mean commute (ACS)
- 26 min
- Congestion delay (TTI)
- —
- Major airports nearby
- 2
Walkability and transit: EPA Smart Location Database (walkability index 1–20; transit trips per hour within a quarter mile at evening peak). Mean commute: Census ACS 2020–2024. Congestion: Texas A&M Transportation Institute Urban Mobility Report, annual hours of delay per auto commuter, only where TTI measures the urban area (a dash elsewhere).
- Physicians per 100k
- 429
- Primary care per 100k
- 76
- Hospital beds per 100k
- 352
- Nearest hospital
- Mercy Hospital of Buffalo, Buffalo · 13 mi
- Nearest 3+ star hospital
- Kaleida Health, Buffalo · 15 mi · 3★
- Hospitals within 30 mi
- 8
Physicians and beds: HRSA Area Health Resources File 2024–2025, county level (a hospital county serves its neighbors too). Hospitals: Medicare Hospital General Information, acute-care and critical-access hospitals with an emergency department; distances are straight line from the city center and ratings are Medicare overall star ratings (1–5).
- Public land (county)
- 2%
- Broadband subscription
- 93%
Public land: share of the county that is open-access public land (USGS PAD-US 4.0). Broadband: Census ACS 2020–2024, households with a broadband subscription of any type.
- College town
- No
- Congregations per 100k residents (county)
- 76.5
- Congregations (county)
- 730
- Adherents per 1,000 residents (county)
- 680
- Evangelical Protestant (share of adherents)
- 9.9%
- Mainline Protestant
- 7.1%
- Catholic
- 68.4%
- Black Protestant
- 6.5%
- Orthodox
- 0.6%
- Other (Latter-day Saints, Jewish, Muslim, Buddhist, Hindu and others)
- 7.5%
2020 U.S. Religion Census (Religious Congregations and Membership Study, via the Association of Religion Data Archives), county level, congregations of every faith: places in one county share these figures. Congregations per 100k is what the score measures; adherents are those the participating groups count (independent congregations and non-participating groups are missing), and the shares are percent of the county's adherents, not of residents.
- Median household income
- $87,800
- Median age
- 50.6 yrs
- Share aged 65+
- 23.5%
- Bachelor's degree or higher
- 18.5%
- Population change since 2020
- -0.4%
- Home price-to-income ratio
- 2.1×
- Diversity index (0–1)
- 0.19
Census ACS 2020–2024; population change from Census estimates (county figure for census-designated places).
- Restaurants (county)
- 2,212
- Arts & entertainment venues (county)
- 427
- Performing-arts companies (county)
- 28
- Event promoters (county)
- 22
- Museums & historic sites (county)
- 21
- Golf courses (county)
- 33
- Golf courses per 100k residents
- 3.5
- Restaurants per 10k residents
- 23.3
- Arts & entertainment per 10k
- 4.5
- Grocery stores per 10k
- 4.5
- Fitness centers per 10k
- 1.5
- Bars per 10k
- 1.9
- Median AQI
- 43 (lower is cleaner)
- Residents on a system with a recent health-based violation (3 yrs)
- 0.1%
- Water violations per 10k served
- 0.1
- Community water systems (county)
- 44
- GOP share, county vote
- 45.2%
- Miles to nearest 1M+ metro
- 14 mi
- Daylight, Dec solstice
- 9.0 h
Restaurants, arts venues, golf courses, theater and music companies, venue promoters and museums: Census County Business Patterns 2022, county level (establishments with paid employees, not seats or quality; the Census withholds some detail for small counties, so a small county's count can be too low; government-run museums are not counted). Median AQI: EPA monitor in the county, else the nearest monitored county within 75 miles, else an older estimate. Drinking water: EPA Safe Drinking Water Information System, county level, health-based violations whose compliance period began 2023–2025; these are regulatory violations, not taste or hardness, and small systems report less consistently. GOP share: 2024 county presidential vote (Alaska: estimate).
- Overall risk
- Relatively High · 98/100
- Coastal flooding
- Relatively Low
- Inland flooding
- Relatively High
- Wildfire
- Very Low
- Hurricane
- Relatively Low
- Tornado
- Relatively High
- Earthquake
- Relatively Low
- Heat wave
- Relatively Moderate
- Drought
- Relatively Low
- Winter weather
- Very High
FEMA National Risk Index v1.20, by county. Ratings reflect expected losses for the whole county, so they rise with population and property value; the Low disaster risk score instead uses expected property loss as a share of property value, which is independent of county size. Hazards that do not occur here are omitted.
Explore further
- WikipediaHistory, geography, demographics, and notable facts(opens in a new tab)
- Google MapsExplore neighborhoods, streets, and surroundings(opens in a new tab)
- Weather & climateCurrent forecast from the National Weather Service(opens in a new tab)
- City governmentFind the official municipal website(opens in a new tab)
- Community eventsUpcoming local events and things to do(opens in a new tab)
- Jobs nearbyCurrent openings on Indeed(opens in a new tab)
- Major employersWho hires in this area(opens in a new tab)
- Local newsLocal newspaper and regional coverage(opens in a new tab)
- Demographics (Data USA)Population, income, education, and employment figures(opens in a new tab)
Your fit
How well would Highland-on-the-Lake fit you?
Rate what matters to you and see your fit here, trade-offs included.